In plum/purple. Buy it here from
elf.com!
To be honest, I was super excited to buy these for a long time. And when I finally got them...let's just say the big reveal could have been better. For someone who is just starting out in makeup, these are fine. They're only $3, and they come in all colors. But for someone looking for a serious eyeliner, look somewhere else. The color fades after a few hours, if you use the shadow, it will crease horribly, even if you use a primer, and the packaging is horrible. For mine, I have to be super careful when I pull off the cap on the shadow side because the whole thing will pop out. It's just very cheap feeling, which I don't like. I have a few other ELF products, and they don't feel as extremely cheap as this one does, so I'm wondering what went wrong in the packaging department.

They colors themselves are really lovely, and pretty true to the picture (don't ever go by the color swatches on the ELF website!). The purple is a warm violet that compliments my brown eyes, and the shadow is a neutral purple that works great for night or day. There does seem to be a medium size of product in the tube, so for the price it's at, it's not that bad.
The Pros:
I really do love these colors, and I love the price, and that's about all I love.
The Cons:
The packaging could be improved, it could not break as often as it does, and they could label the containers better as for which color they are. There are six different colors total, so it would definitely be a problem to find the color you want. I know I already experience this and I own two! I think I will take a small piece of masking tape, color it with a Sharpie and wrap it around the middle so I can tell them apart.
The Bottom Line
5/10
I did expect creasing, because it's not a high quality product, but the amount I had was NOT desirable. As I said, the packaging could be improved. But the colors are great, and there's no parabens or fragrances in this product so at the price point it's at, it's just average. I don't recommend it, and I don't say to go out and buy it. If you're looking for a cheap eyeliner just to keep in your purse for on the go, or if your budget just doesn't allow for higher-end brands, then give it a go!